Blog · 9 November 2026

How to Choose a Web Design Agency: Questions That Separate the Good from the Glossy

Every agency portfolio looks good. The difference shows up in the questions you ask before you sign.

Choosing a web design agency is hard because the thing you are buying does not exist yet. You are looking at past work and listening to a pitch, and both are designed to impress. The way through is to ask questions that are hard to answer with a pitch.

We are an agency, so you should weigh this with that in mind. But these are the questions we would want a prospective client to ask us, and we think any good studio will be glad to answer them.

1. Who will actually do the work?

Many studios are fronted by a salesperson and staffed by juniors, freelancers or an overseas team. That is not automatically a problem, but you deserve to know. Ask who will design and who will build, and whether you will talk to them directly.

2. Can I see work like mine, and can I talk to the client?

A portfolio shows taste. A reference shows how the studio behaves when something goes wrong. Ask for a client in a similar sector or of a similar size, and ask that client how the agency handled changes, delays and the launch itself.

3. What does the price include, in writing?

A good quote lists pages or templates, the content you must supply, how many design rounds and QA rounds are included, and what counts as extra. On our custom projects, for example, two design rounds and one QA round are included, and anything beyond that is quoted separately. Vague quotes become expensive change requests.

4. What do you need from me, and by when?

Most late projects are late because content or feedback arrived late. An experienced studio will tell you plainly what it needs and when. If the answer is “nothing, we’ll handle it”, be sceptical: somebody still has to know your business.

5. How do you handle speed and mobile?

Ask what the agency does to make sites fast, and what scores they aim for on mobile. Google’s Core Web Vitals give concrete targets: Largest Contentful Paint within 2.5 seconds, Interaction to Next Paint under 200 milliseconds and Cumulative Layout Shift under 0.1, measured at the 75th percentile of real visits. An agency that cannot talk about these has probably not been measuring them. You can check any site, including a competitor’s, with our free Site Fighter tool.

6. What happens to my search rankings?

If you already get enquiries from Google, the agency should talk about redirects, preserving page titles and content that earns traffic, and checking Search Console after launch. If search is never mentioned, a redesign may cost you visibility you cannot see you have until it is gone. We cover this in what a premium redesign involves.

7. Can my team edit the site, and what can they break?

Ask for a demonstration of adding a page, changing a price and uploading an image. A good build lets your team do routine updates without a developer and without being able to wreck the design.

8. Who owns the site, the content and the hosting?

You should own the finished site, the content and the domain. Ask what happens if you want to move hosts or leave the agency. If the answer involves penalties or a proprietary system you cannot take with you, think hard.

9. What does support look like after launch?

Sites need updates, security patches and small changes. Ask what is included for the first weeks, what ongoing care costs, and whether it is optional. Pay attention to how quickly the agency replied to your own enquiries: that is a sample of what support will feel like.

10. Will you tell me when I do not need what I asked for?

This one is a character test. Good agencies talk clients out of features that will not help, and sometimes out of the project altogether, with advice like “fix your photography first” or “you need a fortnight of content work before a redesign”. If every answer is “yes, we can do that”, the studio is selling, not advising.

Warning signs

  • A fixed price quoted before anyone has asked what the site is for
  • Pressure to sign this week for a discount that expires
  • No named people on the team page or in the proposal
  • A portfolio of screenshots with no live sites you can open and test on your phone
  • Guaranteed rankings. Nobody can guarantee them

Test them with a small task

If you are torn between two agencies, ask each for a short paid discovery or audit before the full project. A website audit or a scoping sprint costs far less than a rebuild, and it shows how the agency thinks and communicates. We offer both for that reason, and you can see how they are scoped on our website audit page.

If you would like to put these questions to us, start with a conversation. We will tell you honestly whether the project is a good fit.

Common questions

How much should a professional website cost in the UK?

It depends on scope. A fixed-scope small business site is often priced from a couple of thousand pounds, while a custom website with a CMS, integrations and several templates is more. Our own custom websites start from £4,000 and small business sites from £2,000. Be wary of quotes that cannot tell you what is included.

Should I choose a freelancer or an agency?

Neither is automatically better. What matters is who actually does the work, how many projects they are juggling, and what happens if they are unavailable. Ask who will design and build your site and whether you will speak to them directly.

What should a web design contract include?

The scope and deliverables, the number of revision rounds, the payment schedule, a launch date or timeline, who owns the finished site and its content, and what happens to hosting and support afterwards.

Ready to build something that refuses to blend in?

Tell us what you’re building, replacing, or trying to fix. We’ll tell you honestly whether it’s the kind of project we’d be good at.

Discuss a projecthello@shroweb.com

Start a project